Lemon Hill Solar – WHAT?!?!

October 30th, 2026

On October 22, 2026, the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission met to consider the site permit for Lemon Hill Solar (PUC Docket GS-25-126. This meeting was one of the most difficult to watch, and I’m sure glad I wasn’t representing anyone on this project.

ALJ’s Recommendation

I’d read the ALJ’s Recommendation because of a couple of issues raised, particularly karst, and also erosion, an issue in one of the Wisconsin dockets I’d worked on. The ALJ recommended the permit be denied, giving detailed reasons and citing evidence from the record. Denial of an application is rare, I know the Freeborn Wind application was originally denied, the application withdrawn, until Commerce and Xcel changed the rules, moved the goal posts, and applied again. Of course then it sailed through. I’ve not heard of another recommendation of denial, but ? there could be others, I don’t have an eye on every PUC Docket.

And this –I’ve never seen anything like this:

October 22 Public Utilities Commission Meeting: Start at 33:44 (won’t let me embed)

The written order is not out yet… will update this post when it’s available.

PowerOn Midwest Public hearings start on Monday, November 9th. Do mark you calendars, go over what’s in the docket (CN-25-117), and come on down!!

The NOTICE of hearings and release of Environmental Report for the “PowerOn Midwest” 765 kV transmission project (PUC Docket CN-25-117), has landed… See map above. Attached to the Notice is proof they sent out 31,353 notices in the mail! That’s good, but…

WHERE’S THE

ENVIRONMENTAL REPORT?

Environmental Report has arrived, it’s posted down below.

The PowerOn Midwest project is a part of that HUGE MISO 765 kV transmission project from Big Stone, in South Dakota, across Minnesota to Columbia Wisconsin — MISO LRTP numbers 22, 23, 24, 25 and 26. The PowerOn Midwest part is MISO LRTP numbers 22, 23, 24, 25, and Gopher to Badger is part of MISO LRTP #26.

Here’s the Public Hearing schedule, and there’s a virtual public hearing at 6p on the 16th:

Here’s the full Notice:

Environmental Report!

NameAdditional InfoDocument Date
POM_ER.pdf
(27MB)
PowerOn Midwest Environmental Report10/19/2026
AppendixA_ProjectMaps – Part 1 of 4.pdf
(23MB)
PowerOn Midwest Environmental Report – Appendix A: Maps – Part 1 of 410/19/2026
AppendixA_ProjectMaps – Part 2 of 4.pdf
(22MB)
PowerOn Midwest Environmental Report – Appendix A: Maps – Part 2 of 410/19/2026
AppendixA_ProjectMaps – Part 3 of 4.pdf
(22MB)
PowerOn Midwest Environmental Report – Appendix A: Maps – Part 3 of 410/19/2026
AppendixA_ProjectMaps – Part 4 of 4.pdf
(15MB)
PowerOn Midwest Environmental Report – Appendix A: Maps – Part 4 of 410/19/2026
AppendixB_ScopingDecision.pdf
(618KB)
PowerOn Midwest Environmental Report – Appendix B: Scoping Decision10/19/2026
AppendixC_SampleHVTLPermit.pdf
(720KB)
PowerOn Midwest Environmental Report – Appendix C: Sample HVTL Permit10/19/2026
AppendixD-1_ApplicantsScopingComments.pdf
(563KB)
PowerOn Midwest Environmental Report – Appendix D-1: Applicants Scoping Comments10/19/2026
AppendixD-2_ApplicantsVisualSimulations.pdf
(23MB)
PowerOn Midwest Environmental Report – Appendix D-2: Visual Simulations10/19/2026
AppendixD-3_ApplicantsDirectTestimony.pdf
(5MB)
PowerOn Midwest Environmental Report – Appendix D-3: Highway Co-Location Direct Testimony10/19/2026
AppendixE_EMFReview.pdf
(418KB)
PowerOn Midwest Environmental Report – Appendix E: EMF Review10/19/2026

Hot off the press, from W. Ben Johnson, M.D., and just eFiled in both PowerOn Midwest (PUC Docket CN-25-117) and Gopher to Badger (PUC Docket CN-25-121) dockets:

Notice of the Agenda for the Public Utilities Commission October 22, 2026 meeting has two most interesting items. Briefing papers will be out before the 22nd.

The Xcel Electric Service Agreement is interesting because there’s a request to refer this for a Contested Case and to remove the redactions from filings. YES! How is the public to consider this if we don’t know what’s at issue? Some filings below.

The other is the Site Permit for Lemon Hill Solar, the first solar permit I know of where the ALJ Recommended denial (sort of like Freeborn Wind where we got a recommendation of denial, and then Xcel and the Commission went behind closed doors and changed “guidance” to allow “garbage in-garbage out” noise modeling.) Recommendation below.

Check out the ways that the Lemon Hill Solar project did not meet the siting criteria.