Reminder – Transmission Road Show next week
October 21st, 2023
It’s called the “Northland Reliability Project,” proposed by Minnesota Power and Great River Energy. The hearings are spread across the anticipated route for this line:
If you can’t make the meetings, there’s an online meeting too:
Be sure to send in your comments — IN WRITING:
What to comment on? This and more — focus on these issues for your comment to count, to be “relevant” to determining the scope of environmental review:
And be sure to ask for an Advisory Task Force (Minn. Stat. 216E.08), with public appointees, to raise the impacts that only folks on the ground, those potentially affected by this project, would know. In some recent transmission dockets, the Task Forces were comprised ONLY of local government officials, which is NOT the object of task force representation — it’s in the PUBLIC PARTICIPATION statute — the public must invited to apply and members of the public must be selected to serve!
Here’s the transmission line (rough) route map:
More details here on Legalectric:
Xmsn Road Show – Northland Reliability Project
BE THERE OR BE SQUARE!
Update on Summit CO2 pipeline
October 21st, 2023
This good news is about the Summit Carbon Solutions (SCS Carbon Transport LLC)’s Midwest Carbon Express from North Dakota Public Service Commission:
North Dakota regulators deny siting permit for Summit carbon dioxide pipeline; company will reapply
And in trying to find that North Dakota Public Service Commission denial of the “SCS Carbon Transport LLC” (Summit Carbon Solutions) application for the “Midwest Carbon Express” pipeline, I found this map, showing a more extensive intrusion into Minnesota, not just southern Minnesota but way up into central Minnesota:
And the aerial version:
Here’s the North Dakota PSC’s Order:
They’ve filed for Reconsideration, no surprise.
For full SCS Carbon Transport/Midwest Carbon Express docket click HERE!
The Minnesota Summit docket (PPL-22-422) is segmented, so far, just a small part of what’s planned for Minnesota, this part near the North Dakota border. It’s good to know that the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission is aware of the North Dakota denial:
Though the Summit Carbon response seems a bit too optimistic!
Meanwhile, the Scoping Decision is out for this Minnesota Summit docket (PPL-22-422), the segmented 28 mile portion in west-central Minnesota, which means that the Draft EIS will be submitted for comment sometime, though probably not soon — GET READY TO COMMENT:
And the other good news is that I can’t find any other Summit Carbon Solutions, SCS Carbon Transport, or Midwest Carbon Express dockets. Perhaps I’m missing something?? Or perhaps it really is good news…
CO2 pipelines? Navigator, a CO2 pipeline project’s developer, caves!
October 21st, 2023
Got the best news from a client today — the “Heartland Greenway” CO2 pipeline project has been withdrawn, killed, canceled, and/or put on hold:
Navigator kills its $3.5B carbon capture pipeline across Iowa, South Dakota, other states
Major Navigator CO2 pipeline project is on hold while the company reevaluates the route in 5 states
It would cover much of Iowa, and just this 12 mile stretch in Minnesota, starting at the Valero ethanol plant to the east of Welcome, MN:
And while catching up on the Navigator CO2 pipeline, more good news — it’s time to catch up. This good news is about the Summit Carbon Solutions (SCS Carbon Transport LLC)’s Midwest Carbon Express from North Dakota Public Service Commission:
North Dakota regulators deny siting permit for Summit carbon dioxide pipeline; company will reapply
I’ll put this Summit CO2 pipeline info in a separate post — DONE!
City Response to Data Practices Request
October 18th, 2023
“Our” Mayor Wilson is fond of waving around a handful of papers, claiming to have screenshots of Open Meeting Law violations and of Data Breaches by City Council and/or City Commission members.
Received today, “Response” which I don’t think is responsive (and again below):
Check the handwritten comments – I doubt that’s his writing!! Note also, claim hand-written in that Becky Norton is using her private page yet making comments “speaking as Elected Official” — FALSE (Wilson forgets his ex parte letter to judge opening with “As Red Wing’s Mayor...”); a written comment on October 13 that Moderator Laura McDonough is Evan Brown’s wife (I really doubt that she was Moderating last week); that Anna Ostendorf is on Charter Commission (DOH, School Board… perhaps he means Ann Vogel or Anne Robertson?); “posting pics without knowing” (ha ha ha ha ha…) and I guess I shouldn’t say “WTAF.” Well… WTAF!
As you may recall, after that Council meeting, August 28th, 2023, where he TWICE waved around a handful of papers making these claims of violations of Open Meeting Law and Data Breqches, I fired off a Data Practices Act Request. If, that is IF, there are such violations and breaches, let’s see the proof, get it to the City Attorney, and the City must investigate! Amy Mace, City Attorney, did say on the record that the City would be interested in such violations.
That DPA Request was denied, with a claim that Wilson was using a “hypothetical,” which was off, because he was referring to specifics, so I sent a follow up request:
Today, just received a response, though I think that this is only part of the larger handful of screenshots, as these seem to focus mostly on yours truly! If this is really all he has, that’s a long way from Open Meeting Law violations and Data Breaches. And dig the handwritten comments, how petty can you get!
Just WOW… pathetic…
Big picture of transmission in Minnesota
October 11th, 2023
YES!
Can you believe it? A media report listing much of the new transmission proposed for Minnesota. The plans are being noticed!!!
Minnesota Utilities Completing 19 Transmission Line Upgrades
And here’s the list — yes, it’s extensive:
CapX2020 Brookings 2nd 345 kV Circuit 60 Xcel Energy/GRE/OTP/ MRES/CMPAS Lincoln, Lyon
CapX2020 Helena 2nd 345 kV Circuit 39 Xcel Energy/GRE/OTP/ MRES/CMPAS Scott, Dakota
Hoot Lake-Fergus Falls 115 kV 2 OTP/MRES Otter Tail
Morris-Grant County 115 kV 24 MRES Grant, Stevens
Franklin-Ft Ridgely-Swan Lake 115 kV 39 Xcel Energy Nicollet
Swan Lake-Wilmarth 115 kV 16 Xcel Energy Nicollet
Red Rock-Raptor 115 kV 7 Xcel Energy Washington
AAR* – Johnson Jct.-Morris 115 kV 15 GRE/OTP Big Stone, Stevens
Canby-Granite Falls 115 kV 39 OTP Yellow, Medicine
AAR* – Inman-Elmo-Parkers Prairie-Miltona-Alexandria 115 kV 34 GRE/OTP Otter Tail, Douglas
AAR* – Mud Lake-Benton 230 kV 51 GRE/MP Crow Wing, Morrison, Benton
Rogers Lake-High Bridge 115 kV 0.5 Xcel Energy Ramsey, Dakota
Wakefield-St. Cloud 115 kV 18 Xcel Energy Stearns
Pleasant Valley-Byron 161 kV 17 Xcel Energy/GRE/SMMPA Mower, Dodge, Olmsted
Big Stone-Blair 230 kV 33 OTP Grant, Deuel (SD)
Coon Creek-Terminal 345 kV 14 Xcel Energy Anoka, Ramsey
Coon Creek-Kohlman Lake 345 kV 20 Xcel Energy Anoka, Ramsey
AAR* – Forbes-Iron Range 230 kV 34 MP St. Louis, Itasca
AAR* – Blackberry-Riverton 230 kV 67 MP Crow Wing, Aitkin, Itasca