WI Petition for Rulemaking – Solar siting rules are needed
December 7th, 2018
Photo of DOE project in Alamosa, under 30 MW
There’s a 300MW solar project proposed for southern Wisconsin, in Iowa County. Thing is, as with Minnesota and large wind (PUC denies Reconsideration re: Wind Rulemaking), there are no siting rules for solar in Wisconsin! Really, no rules! Typically thus far, solar projects are 2-10 MW. This one proposed is 300MW! Central station power to put it mildly.
Not only are there no siting rules, but there is no Environmental Impact Statement required for a project covering 3,500 acres!
WHAT?!?!
So on behalf of Jewell Jinkins Intervenors, I’ve just filed this Petition for Rulemaking to get them going on solar rules.
Petition for Rulemaking_JJI_Solar_FINAL_Signed
We shall see what, if anything, they do.
PUC denies Reconsideration re: Wind Rulemaking
December 6th, 2018
We know who you are, and we saw what you did… and didn’t!
No surprise. Today the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission rejected Goodhue Wind Truth’s Petition for Reconsideration of the Commission’s denial of our Petition for Rulemaking. Rules, who needs rules… about 2,500 MW of wind has been sited in Minnesota WITHOUT LARGE WIND SPECIFIC SITING RULES AND/OR STANDARDS! Really! And the Commission doesn’t seem to regard that as a problem. Large wind is sited using SMALL WIND/COUNTY SITING STANDARDS, not intended for large wind. And the Commission doesn’t seem to regard that as a problem. Large wind is sited using MPCA’s industrial noise standards which were admittedly NOT designed with wind in mind. And the Commission doesn’t seem to regard that as a problem. Large wind is sited using a Commerce boilerplate site permit with 1,000 foot setbacks and staff has no idea where that 1,000 foot setback came from (it’s contrary to even the small wind standards, and there’s no rule or standard of 1,000 ft!). And the Commission doesn’t seem to regard that as a problem.
Here’s the rest of the background information:
GWT Rulemaking Reconsideration is 12/6
November 21st, 2018
Wind Rulemaking — Petition for Reconsideration
October 16th, 2018
Today’s Wind Rulemaking Comments
August 24th, 2018
Notice – PUC wants wind rulemaking comments!
August 2nd, 2018
Just filed – Petition for Wind Siting Rulemaking
July 30th, 2018
RUS EIS is released for Cardinal-Hickory Creek Transmission
December 3rd, 2018
It’s out, the USDA’s RUS EIS for Cardinal-Hickory Creek transmission project:
Draft Environmental Impact Statement – November 2018
From the RUS Notice, how to send in comments and list of public meetings:
GWT Rulemaking Reconsideration is 12/6
November 21st, 2018
I often use this photo, because it represents one simple fact: Sometimes things go off the rails. Wind siting in Minnesota is one of those things, we have no wind specific siting criteria!
Thursday, December 6th, we’re back at the Commission, where they’ll address Goodhue Wind Truth’s Petition for Reconsideration, or not (and toss it in the circular file).
Here’s some background:
Wind Rulemaking — Petition for Reconsideration
October 16th, 2018
Today’s Wind Rulemaking Comments
August 24th, 2018
Lots of filing in Wisconsin
November 20th, 2018
Apparently Invenergy doesn’t like the idea that we’re intervening in their Wisconsin dockets. I guess after Freeborn Wind, it’s not hard to understand why.
Intervention in Badger Hollow HUGE 300 MW solar project docket — approved by the Administrative Law Judge (Docket 9697-CE-100):
And then the related dockets, the transmission line and the acquisition docket, appropriately known as the BS docket, our intervention, their objection, and our response. The transmission docket (Docket 9697-CE-101):
Jewell Jinkins_101_Intervention_FINAL
9697-CE-101 Badger Hollow – Response to Request for Intervention (Objection!)
And the acquisition BS docket (Docket 5-BS-228):
Jewell Jinkins_228_Intervention_CORRECTED
Oh, and the Cardinal Hickory Creek 345 kV Transmission Line! Docket 5-CE-146.
Jewell Jinkins Intervenors_Cardinal-Hickory Creek_Intervention
To look up any of these dockets, go to the Wisconsin Public Service Commission’s Search site, and plug in the numbers.
Meanwhile, we’re waiting on the Minnesota Commission meeting on Reconsideration for our Rulemaking Petition, and waiting on two orders, project and transmission, for Freeborn Wind.
And around all these filings, I’ve been to band practice, made wild rice and garbanzo salad, and I hear a Ferndale Market turkey calling…
What a long week it’s been! WHAT? Tuesday?!?! No, really?!?!